​Title: The Bone Clocks
Author: David Mitchell
Publisher: Random House
Hardcover ISBN: 978-1-4000-6567-7
eBook ISBN: 978-0-8129-9473-5
624 pp.


     Forty years of practicing psychotherapy have left me somewhat immune to the bittersweet tragicomedies of life. At least, I find myself these days just a bit short on tears. But the last ten pages of David Mitchell’s new book, The Bone Clocks, turned me back into a weeper.
     The book is too big and too complex a story for easy summary. Also, it’s too damn good. Like great music or a superb dinner, The Bone Clocks needs to be encountered, wrestled with, and savored. Not munched like Cliff Notes. Let me, however, offer a few hints about what you’re in for when you read Mitchell's masterpiece:

  • Hint 1: The book tackles enormous themes, with nary a didactic word or explanatory passage. Despite the themes' depth, Mitchell shows everything though the actions and interactions of compelling flesh-and-blood characters, drawn with realism, emotion, and precision. What are the themes? Here are a few (there are more): Try life and death (and life after death). Try climate change and its impact on civilization. How about the birth, death, and rebirth of human society? Or the possibility of mental evolution to levels far beyond ours?
  • Hint 2: There are at least four, count ‘em, four, protagonists – Holly Sykes, Hugo Lamb, Marinus, and Crispin Hershey – and each is simultaneously an antagonist to at least one of the others. (And that doesn’t even count the actual bad-guy and bad-gal antagonists in the plot.) Even the most dreadful characters seduced my reluctant sympathy – and I fell in love with Holly Sykes by page 10.
  • Hint 3: The four protagonists’ stories are vivid and compelling near-novellas in their own right, but each is entirely, grippingly, and integrally woven into the fabric of the whole novel. Everything -- and I mean everything! -- coheres and contributes to an inexorable march to the final climax. It's all there in the last pages. Although the enemies seem alien at first, we realize by the book's end that, in Pogo's immortal words, "we have met the enemy, and he is us."
  • Hint 4: Arthur C. Clarke’s Third Law is "any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." You can consider The Bone Clocks to be magical realism. Clarke's law holds true, though, because all the magical elements of the story turn out to be kin to the "miraculous" actions of some advanced Tibetan Buddhist lamas, doing "magical" things with their profound mental training. To me, it would be more accurate to call Mitchell's style technological realism, if you're willing to consider sophisticated mental abilities to be like "sufficiently advanced technologies." It's a semantic stretch, but when you read the book, you'll get it. 
  • Hint 5: Despite having 624 pages, the novel appears to end at page 545! Then, without warning, we’re in an entirely (well, not entirely) new story, set eighteen years later! A seventy-nine page epilogue? Nope. For twenty or more of those pages, I kept asking “Where the hell is he going with this?” Finally, befuddled once again (Mitchell’s story-telling is nothing if not delightfully befuddling), I gave up and let myself sink into this last masterful tale – and that’s when the tears started.
  • Hint 6: The ending, specifically the last seven pages, is perhaps the most bittersweet – or perhaps I should write, sorrowful-uplifting – prose I have ever read. To my mind, the very last line is nothing short of a masterpiece.


     That ending and that last line are what opened me to weep deeply, to let the sorrow and the hope Mitchell portrays so profoundly enter my consciousness fully. I could let the anguish and the aspiration of Holly Sykes – like those of so many clients over forty years – take hold of my emotions as deeply as almost any book has ever done. And so The Bone Clocks proved redemptive – at least for me. I hope it will for you as well.​​​​

Book Thoughts